Skip to main content

The Great Filter - Does It Lie Within the Human Consciousness?

 


Hello readers, this is my first article of 2021 and I couldn't resist myself from going back to one of  my favorite topics, the great filter. In this article, I want to discuss about the so called 'great filter'. In the context of the Fermi Paradox and the mind boggling rarity of intelligent (or even basic) life on planets outside our own, a concept of the 'great filter' was thought of. In simple terms, the filters are some challenges put forward by the universe for any kind of life to develop.

As originally proposed by Robin Hanson, there are many steps in the path of evolution. One or more of these steps are so improbable that the genesis of life from dead matter is almost impossible elsewhere. However, all the steps discussed in the original paper in a sense challenges thrown by the universe or mother nature. I think one more challenge is present which is intrinsic and is purely originating in the human consciousness. This 'great filter' is closely associated to the section named 'rethinking the social theories'.

In this article I wish to introduce you to the concept of the great filter, what events were (or are) thought of as great filters, how it plays an important role in the development of life, and finally, are we currently in a great filter? Finally, and most importantly, can human consciousness also be an intrinsic filter?

In conclusion of his paper, Dr Hanson says, 

No alien civilizations have substantially colonized our solar system or systems nearby. Thus among the billion trillion stars in our past universe, none has reached the level of technology and growth that we may soon reach. This one data point implies that a Great Filter stands between ordinary dead matter and advanced exploding lasting life. And the big question is: How far along this filter are we?
In the same paper Dr Hanson lists some steps which we humans took in our path of evolution and also explains how improbable or hard they were to achieve. The list begins with finding the right solar system, formation of first biological molecule and ends with a development of civilization capable of colonizing the universe. 

As one goes on reading the paper further one realizes that these steps are incredibly difficult to happen. Even if there is another path to evolution those steps will be similarly improbable or harder. 

In my opinion the list is missing one very important factor and that is the development of consciousness. Because, however improbable, we humans have walked very far that path of evolution and have reached a stage where we are dreaming of terraforming mars and other celestial bodies in our own solar system. Along with humans, there are billions of other species that call this planet home. They have evolved too for millions of years. Many of them have been on this earth for eons more than humans do. The only thing that differentiates us from them is the development of consciousness. 

This consciousness has given us an ability to question everything around us including the very nature of reality. However, this is a double edged sword as this consciousness can entangle our mind in the problems stemming from consciousness and can deter us from the goal of colonizing the universe. 

If you see around the world, human beings are overly attached to the earthly pleasures and problems. We have given too much importance to the illusion of money. This has created a comfort zone for humans and created an ultimate goal of ruling this world when there is a literally infinite universe remains unexplored. Another aspect is the difficulty in becoming a space faring civilization. We can say as much as we can that we want to colonize universe the fact remains that it is an extremely difficult feat to achieve. A combination of these two factors has put a glass ceiling to achievements of humanity. The consciousness plays a great role in this glass ceiling. Inherently, it cuts the desire to achieve the nearly improbable feat and makes humans complacent.  

To sum up, what if there are many civilizations as advanced as us but are sufficiently spaced apart. Like us, they are overly attached to their planet's pleasures and problems and for them as well the space travel (to colonize) remains a nearly impossible feat. Ultimately, their desire to rule their planet overpowers the desire to leave the home planet for universe's exploration. If this is the case, then the great filter really lies within the human consciousness and not in universe's conditions or other steps of evolution.


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

In the Abyss of the Cosmos: Confronting the Terrifying Choice Between Absolute Solitude and the Haunting Presence of the Unknown

O ne of the most profound questions humanity faces is: Are we alone in the universe? Despite the vastness of space and the abundance of potentially life-supporting planets, we haven't, at least officially, encountered any extraterrestrial life forms. This leads to a deeper contemplation: Which is more unsettling—being alone in the universe or not? In my view, being alone is the more daunting prospect. Here's why: Life is an Anomaly and not a Rule : If we are truly alone, it implies that the life and especially the intelligent life is just an anomaly. It is not a common occurrence as a result of certain life generating conditions. Essentially, life then becomes a glitch in the normal order of the universe. Emotional Implication : Being alone may lead to being lonely on a cosmic level. It eliminates the possibility of any sort of "cultural exchange". The dreadful solitude will deny any chance of sharing the mysteries of the universe and existential thoughts with anyone ...

Nasadiya Suktam : The Creation Hymn - A tale before time, exploring the "Nasadiya Suktam" through a modern lens

Even though I am not qualified to discuss deeper cosmological and philosophical questions, I am always fascinated by these topics. For example, ever since I heard about the big bang in school, I have always wonderd that what was there before big bang?! I am sure all the great minds in cosmology are working hard to find an answer to this question. But my mind was blown when I learned that there is a Hymn from Rigveda that precisely asks these questions. That proved two things, first, this question, how everything started is unanswered for millenia. And secondly, the people who asked it at least 4500 years ago were not primitive by any measure.  Asking questions like this shows a certain level of advanced thinking. Excusing myself for a little detour I would like to take this opportunity to point out that this has been a theme in the ancient vedic texts. The vedic texts are a treasure trove for philosophical discussions. Moving back to the topic, this hymn from Rigveda is in the 10t...

Abiogenesis Vs Panspermia - Why Life is Extremely Rare in the Universe?

T he very first or one of the very first candidates for the great filter is the first instance of the genesis of organic matter. In case of earth, two prominent candidates that come out on top as the answers to this question are 'panspermia' and 'abiogenesis'. Both of these questions answer many questions and give rise to many others. One important thing to keep in mind is that these two are competing theories only in case of earth. If we consider the universe as a whole abiogenesis has the potential to answer the question how does life start anywhere? This will be more clear as we discuss these in more detail in this article. In this article we will briefly see both the concepts and some of the intriguing possibilities arsing from them. Also, we will see how this ties up with the great filter hypothesis and the rarity of life in the universe.  Panspermia The word ' panspermia ' is derived from the Greek words "Pan" meaning all and "Sperma" m...