Skip to main content

Multiverse and Simulation Hypothesis - A (Seeming) Paradox

Hello Readers,

The more I think about the simulation hypothesis the more intriguing possibilities come to my mind. One of them is the apparent paradox between the simulation hypothesis and the multiverse theory. The idea stems from s simple thought, for creating such an elaborate simulation the computational power required will be astronomically (pun intended) high, therefore, anyone creating such a simulation would go for creating only 'one' simulation. However, the one creating this simulation will be outside the simulation or will be in a different universe which ultimately proves the multiverse theory. 

Now let's dive a little deeper in this chain of thoughts. In 2017, Zohar Ringel and Dmitry Kovrizhi published a paper which shows that just storing information about a couple of hundred electrons would require a computer memory that would physically require more atoms than exist in the universe. This paper also argues that the complexity of such a simulation grows exponentially with every particle added to the simulation. This essentially makes any such simulation unworkable, not just practically but in principle as well. 

This really steals the thunder from the whole idea of the simulated reality as we have discussed in previous articles. But, one thing I have learned over the years from the forefathers of science is never say never. One glaring example is of Lord Kelvin who famously quoted in 1902, "No balloon and no aeroplane will ever be practically successful" and just 4 years later the Wright brothers were making giant strides in the field which eventually took the mankind to the moon. On the side note, contrary to the common belief, Lord Kelvin never predicted the so called "death of physics".

On the similar lines, I dare to disagree with Ringel and Kovrizhi partially for the sake of argument. Let's assume some other advanced civilization makes sufficient progress in computation and achieves a simulation of an entire universe, the energy required for this gargantuan task would be so large that it "seems" impossible to simulate such multiple simulations (Here, I am a little shaky, I have not found any notable references on how much energy would be required for such a task).

In essense, any civilization which is technologically advanced enough to work up such a simulation will have limitations of energy to run such a simulation and will not create multiple simulations. However, to create a simulation that civilization has to be out of the simulation which would be the 'other' universe, hence proving the multiverse hypothesis. 

To sum up, this seems to be a paradox to me but I am sure there will be some logical solution to this. I would love to discuss more on this if you readers would like to get in touch with me. 

Cheers,

Maximilian

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

The unsettling possibility of human beings as the focal animal: A thought experiment exploring the hypothetical framework of possible cosmic observers

Back in 2008, a motherlode  of western lowland gorillas was discovered by scientists in the remote, inaccessible regions of the Congo. As a lifelong admirer of Steve Irwin and his wildlife conservation efforts, I was overjoyed by the news. I closely followed the subsequent efforts to study these magnificent creatures and was particularly intrigued by the methodology adopted. Initially, every possible precaution was taken to ensure no direct contact with them. They were, for the most part, unaware that they were being observed. This has been a standard approach in wildlife research for a long time now. This news, and the global attention it received, resurfaced in my mind recently amid the discussion and furor surrounding the arrival of 3i/Atlas . It was not merely this latest interstellar object that prompted the connection, but the broader sequence of events that some scientists, notably Dr. Avi Loeb  . The similarity between Dr. Loeb’s hypothesis and the earlier example of w...

Nasadiya Suktam : The Creation Hymn - A tale before time, exploring the "Nasadiya Suktam" through a modern lens

Even though I am not qualified to discuss deeper cosmological and philosophical questions, I am always fascinated by these topics. For example, ever since I heard about the big bang in school, I have always wonderd that what was there before big bang?! I am sure all the great minds in cosmology are working hard to find an answer to this question. But my mind was blown when I learned that there is a Hymn from Rigveda that precisely asks these questions. That proved two things, first, this question, how everything started is unanswered for millenia. And secondly, the people who asked it at least 4500 years ago were not primitive by any measure.  Asking questions like this shows a certain level of advanced thinking. Excusing myself for a little detour I would like to take this opportunity to point out that this has been a theme in the ancient vedic texts. The vedic texts are a treasure trove for philosophical discussions. Moving back to the topic, this hymn from Rigveda is in the 10t...

Abiogenesis Vs Panspermia - Why Life is Extremely Rare in the Universe?

T he very first or one of the very first candidates for the great filter is the first instance of the genesis of organic matter. In case of earth, two prominent candidates that come out on top as the answers to this question are 'panspermia' and 'abiogenesis'. Both of these questions answer many questions and give rise to many others. One important thing to keep in mind is that these two are competing theories only in case of earth. If we consider the universe as a whole abiogenesis has the potential to answer the question how does life start anywhere? This will be more clear as we discuss these in more detail in this article. In this article we will briefly see both the concepts and some of the intriguing possibilities arsing from them. Also, we will see how this ties up with the great filter hypothesis and the rarity of life in the universe.  Panspermia The word ' panspermia ' is derived from the Greek words "Pan" meaning all and "Sperma" m...